Woman sues over pothole in KZN

27 January 2009 | Road Safety Highlights


27 January 2009   
 
Pietermaritzburg - A woman is suing the KwaZulu-Natal provincial government for R1.1m over injuries she sustained in an accident allegedly caused by a massive pothole on the R33 between Keats Drift and Tugela Ferry on December 6, 2004.

Hluphile Elda Zuma, 53, lost her arm after the accident.

According to documents before Judge Jan Combrink in the Pietermaritzburg High Court, the pothole in question was allegedly nine metres long and 2.5 metres wide at its widest point.

KZN Premier S'bu Ndebele and Transport MEC Bheki Cele are defending the part-heard case, which is proceeding in the high court this week.

The driver of the taxi, Zamani Langa - who has been accused of negligent driving - and taxi operator DK Sithole, have been joined in the matter as third parties.

Negligence

Zuma alleges that provincial employees responsible for the upkeep of all provincial roads in KwaZulu-Natal were negligent for failing to keep the road in a safe condition.

It is alleged on her behalf that those responsible for doing so, failed to regularly inspect the road, failed to repair the road, failed to erect signs warning motorists of the dangerous condition of the road and failed to close the road or sections of it until the potholes were repaired.

It is alleged in the court papers that, as a result of their negligence, the vehicle in which Zuma was a passenger overturned, causing an injury which resulted in the amputation of her arm below the elbow, as well as other injuries.

Her claim totalling R1 181 600 is for past and future medical costs, her disability, pain, shock, loss of earnings and loss of future earning capacity.

According to court documents, Zuma worked as a chef at Church of Scotland Hospital in Tugela Ferry at the time of the crash, and could no longer continue with her work due to her injury.

Financial constraints

The province has pleaded that its responsibility to maintain provincial roads is governed by section 9 of the KZN Roads Act, which sets out that the minister is "within available financial resources" responsible for the construction and maintenance of provincial roads.

They allege that their employees were not wilful or negligent, but did not do what they should have done "by reason of limited financial constraints".

The province further alleges that the negligent driving of the taxi driver, contributed to or was the sole cause of the accident.

The case is continuing.
[ Story by Ingrid Oellermann appeared in The Witness]

 

Share This Page

Tell a friend icon Tell a Friend | Fax machine icon Print this Page

News Articles

21 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
An armed robbery was reported at a local Supermarket on Lenham Drive at approximately 19h30 on Friday evening, when four armed suspects targeted the store. KZN VIP Tactical Unit and Response Officers were dispatched to the scene following reports of the incident. The suspects reportedly entered the
21 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
A man has been arrested in Benoni after allegedly fabricating a #hijacking and #kidnapping incident in an attempt to mislead the police and conceal his unlawful activities. On Friday, 20 November 2026, Benoni #SAPS members launched an investigation following a report by the complainant, who alleged
21 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
A white Volkswagen Polo TSI and a white Isuzu D-Max collided on the R102 at the Old Inanda Road junction in Verulam – KZN this evening (Friday, 20/11/2026). The Reaction Unit South Africa (RUSA) Operations Centre received a call for assistance at approximately 18:32 and dispatched Reaction Officers
21 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
A black Hyundai i10 collided with a boundary wall and motorised driveway gate at a property on Trenance Park Place in Phoenix – KZN this evening (Friday, 20/11/2026). Members of Reaction Unit South Africa (RUSA) responded after a resident contacted the Operations Centre for assistance. On arrival
20 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
The Minister of Transport, Ms Barbara Creecy, and the Deputy Minister of Transport, Mr Mkhuleko Hlengwa, warmly congratulate South African Airways on being ranked 7th globally in TIME’s inaugural World’s Best Airlines 2027, with an impressive score of 92.16. SAA also secured 2nd place
20 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
The Commissioner of the Border Management Authority (BMA), Dr Michael Masiapato, has confirmed that the BMA Integrity Unit, working in collaboration with Crime Intelligence, the Free State Organised Crime Unit, the South African Police Service (SAPS), the Department of Home Affairs and the Tactical Response
20 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
What began as a response to a motor vehicle collision on Thursday evening became a scene of terror when gunfire erupted near the corner of Lenham and Westham Drive. One man lost his life, and several other people were injured, including a female paramedic who had come to help. KZN VIP emergency teams,
20 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
Durban Metro Police advises motorists and members of the public of traffic arrangements for the Carling Knockout Cup Semi-Final between Stellenbosch FC and Orlando Pirates, scheduled to take place on Saturday, 21 November 2026, at Moses Mabhida Stadium. The match is expected to attract approximately
20 Nov 2026 | From Arrive Alive
For some people, a job is simply a way to earn a living. For others, it becomes a place to grow, build relationships and find a second family. That is the story behind 96 Hyundai Automotive South Africa employees who were honoured for a remarkable 1,060 combined years of service. All based in Gauteng,

News Archive